Score One for Ennui
Mr. Aguirre-Sacasa must have had a horrible time in high school; no doubt akin to the one portrayed in this play. St. Joseph’s is a sports-driven Catholic school for boys and woe to the non-jock and, heaven forbid, the nascent homosexuals in the student body. The playwright’s character-surrogate is obviously the role of Justin who is the most articulate and together homosexual high school senior ever born.
The impact of the scenery is significant in that it almost totally exists of a hundred or more immoveable and intractable sports trophies in well-lighted niches; even the ceiling drips with them. This, of course, symbolizes the school and its shiny implacability crushes anything that goes on below, thus proving that nothing that anybody says or does is going to change one whit the policies and self-serving politics of the church’s saintly dogma.
A star student/athlete is accused of a fairly rotten heterosexual crime and the effect of this event reverberates throughout the pre-ivy high school, and the lives of the families on both sides are ruined (maybe). No one is totally innocent, including the school itself. Oh, yeah, although not alluded to in the play; placing this scandal in 1988 precludes the truly horrendous crimes subsequently perpetrated (and covered up) by the Catholic church.
Scott Ellis directs with zero nuance. The actors seem to be forever putting on and taking off their coats and our poor fallen hero seems to not understand in the least what he’s done wrong. The poor actor stuck in this role even has to say “Oh, Mom” in a variety of Beaver Cleaver ways. Oh, Mawummmmmm, like she was chastising him that he forgot to eat his Cheerios.
If Mr. Aguirre-Sacasa thinks he’s exacted revenge on his old school, he’s mistaken. St. Joseph’s 10; playwright 3.